which one of my siggys are better?

[Akio950]

this one...
http://i6.tinypic.com/6labw4o.png <------this was made by ColdDisguise... she's awesome!

or my current one...
please tell me why...

[Bockor]

current one.
The first one is to small and has a little font, the current one is mutch better..

[DJready]

currect one. And a lil suggestion dont make that bevel around it or frame whatever it is, rather make a 2pix. stroke around it maybe black color